National Veterans Foundation News

Trauma in Iraq Leads to Drama in Oregon

Published November 3rd, 2009

 

JOHN DAY, OREGON -- Later, after the defense attorney wept and the judge put away his robe and the jurors drove home in the fading light, the consequences of war hung over this town of 1,845 like wood smoke on an autumn eve. . .

 

War has changed the Oregon Army National Guard, which has deployed troops on 8,400 tours in Iraq and Afghanistan since 9/11. It turned the state's emergency volunteers into combat veterans. 

And last month, a Grant County jury considered how much war changed Jessie Bratcher. For the first time in Oregon, and among the first cases nationwide, post-traumatic stress from serving in Iraq was the defense for murder. . .

 

The state needed to prove only that Bratcher intentionally killed Medina, a crime that carried 25 years in prison. 

The prosecutor scoffed at the argument that "anyone who serves in the military is a trained killer who we cannot trust. That is not the case. The vast majority of young people who serve are good, honorable people who contribute to society." 

The defense claimed Bratcher was either guilty only of manslaughter -- unable to stop himself because of an extreme emotional disturbance -- or that he committed murder but was legally insane due to a mental disease or defect, PTSD. The judge could then sentence Bratcher to psychiatric care instead of prison. 

Late on the seventh day of the trial, defense attorney Sario stood. At 65, he was almost 25 years older than the prosecutor and on his third career. The son of a Finnish mathematician who immigrated to teach alongside Albert Einstein, Sario had been a forester and an assistant prosecutor before taking the defense job in Grant County. Ninety percent of his cases pitted him against prosecutor Joslin. A community theater director and actor, Sario opened the defense by calling the case a Shakespearean tragedy. 

"And it ends as Shakespearean tragedies do: everyone loses." 

He closed with the words of 20th-century writer Kahlil Gibran: "The righteous is not innocent of the deeds of the wicked." 

Sario asked the jury: "Is this what we want to do with the young men who volunteer to serve our country?" The jury quickly split between those who believed Bratcher was guilty of murder and those who believed he was mentally ill. . .

 

The president of the National Veterans Foundation said its crisis hot line has received more domestic violence calls. But foundation President Shad Meshad  predicted that the full impact of Iraq and Afghanistan lies ahead. Meshad, whose pioneer work in PTSD helped create the VA's Vet Centers, said most violent crime by Vietnam vets didn't happen until the 1980s, well after that war ended. He expects that deploying for multiple tours, common to Iraq and Afghanistan, will drive numbers higher. 

"I see a tsunami coming," he said.

 

Read the full Oregonian story by Julie Sullivan

 

 

 

To support the National Veterans Foundation and its programs to assist Veterans in crisis, please visit

www.help-veterans.org.

 

 

View More NVF News Alerts
send to a friend

Support Veterans

16 Cents For Vets
Jobs For Vets
Help Homeless Veterans
Remember The Heroes
Defending American Independence
Honor Veterans Day

NVF News Alerts

March 23rd, 2010
Braley Resolution Honoring 65th Anniversary of Iwo Jima Unanimously Passes House

In honor of our World War II Veterans and the 65th Anniversary of the raising of the American flag at Iwo Jima, the National Veterans Foundation just released Semper Fi , a historical tribute tRead More

December 16th, 2009
National Veterans Foundation Extends Hours to Meet Growing Veteran Need

On January 4, 2010 the National Veterans Foundation (NVF) will extend the hours of its Lifeline for Vets™ to accommodate a growing number of Veterans who need help with crisis intervention and resource referrals.  The Lifeline provides assisRead More

December 2nd, 2009
Obama Announces 30,000 Troop Surge in Afghanistan

“While we understand the strategic reasons for this decision,” said National Veterans Foundation President Shad Meshad, “we are deeply concerned about the welfare of the troops that will be deployed.  This is the longest, all-volRead More

November 5th, 2009
Twelve Killed in Fort Hood Shootings

 FORT HOOD, Texas – The U.S. Army said 12 people were killed and 31 wounded in a shooting rampage on the Fort Hood Army base in Texas.

Read More
November 3rd, 2009
Trauma in Iraq Leads to Drama in Oregon

The defense claimed Bratcher was either guilty only of manslaughter -- unable to stop himself because of an extreme emotional disturbance -- or that he committed murder but was legally insane due to a mental disease or defect, PTSD. The judge could theRead More


Veteran News